100% SATISFACTION GUARANTANTEED!
1.800.953.7437
Made in traditional Midtown style, this is for the true cheesecake lover. 100% cream cheese! Cooked in water bath allowing the cake to rise slowly to make it a dense cake, yet light in texture. We also dust the pan with toasted breadcrumbs as instead of graham cracker crumbs! We don't miss a step in bringing you this authentic dessert that New York made famous. Oh! By the way! This cake is all natural, no artificial ingredients and no Jell-0!
We ship on Monday & Wednesday so you would receive on Wednesday or Friday.

All orders must be received by 12 Midnight EST., to ship the following day via air. For example, order by Sunday, 12 midnight EST and receive pie on Wednesday. Or order your pie by Tuesday 12 midnight EST and receive your pie on Friday.

We only ship in the continental U.S. and do not ship to Alaska, Hawaii or Canada at this time.



New York Style Cheesecake
This is the real deal (ok, so it's not made in New York) but it is made in the traditional Midtown style. It’s poured into our buttery graham crust and cooked in a water bath ..
$79.95
Blueberry Cheesecake
This cheesecake is sure to be a winner anywhere in the country, so don’t let the New Englanders gobble this one up by themselves.
$79.95
Sea Salt Caramel Cheesecake
Just when you thought you have tasted the best cheesecake ever Mike's Pies has raised the bar again.
$79.95
SHIPPING (Required): 
SHIPPING (Required): 
SHIPPING (Required): 



Turtle Cheesecake
This is the Mike’s Pies version of a Turtle Cheesecake. By appearance it looks like all the others, chocolate, caramel, pecans, etc.… but when you bite into it you will agree it is totally different.
$79.95
Strawberry Cheesecake
Our N.Y. Cheesecake with strawberries swirled in to create a wonderful Florida dessert!
$79.95
Irish Cream Cheesecake
We start with our award winning cheesecake and flavor it with a lot of BAILEY’S® THE ORIGINAL IRISH CREAM and a touch of JAMESON® IRISH WHISKEY.
$79.95
SHIPPING (Required): 
SHIPPING (Required): 
SHIPPING (Required): 



Blackberry Cheesecake
Jaw-dropping blackberry filling is swirled into our traditional New York Style Cheesecake for a combination that will have you wondering why we’re not called Mike’s Cheesecakes.
$79.95
SHIPPING (Required): 







vastplanet