|We ship on Monday & Wednesday so you would receive on Wednesday or Friday. |
All orders must be received by 12 Midnight EST., to ship the following day via air. For example, order by Sunday, 12 midnight EST and receive pie on Wednesday. Or order your pie by Tuesday 12 midnight EST and receive your pie on Friday.
We only ship in the continental U.S. and do not ship to Alaska, Hawaii or Canada at this time.
Winner of 4 National Pie Championships!!
If you want the true taste of an "Authentic" Key Lime Pie, this is it!
This recipe goes all the way back to Grandma Smithís kitchen, with a little meddling by Mike.
We combine tart apples with just the right amount of sugar...
So using the basic ingredients from the cupboard and buttermilk, they created a pie that spills over with the light creamy flavor of butter with a hint of buttermilk.
Our light and creamy filling is made with Reese's® peanut butter and topped with Reese's Peanut Butter Cups.
Then Mike pours it on with...
Itís Mike at his decadent best.
Mike whips up a fluffy coffee mousse and piles it onto a chocolate cookie crust...
This is the Pie that makes Mike's Grandma proud!
A third generation recipe, it begins with a flaky pastry...